Mariah Carey successfully received a lawsuit that accused her of ripping the lyrics and melody of another song for her Hit holiday track everything I want Christmas Are you, with a judge who finds 'an absence of evidence' to support accusations, the singer copied her tune from another.
Carey, 55, was accused of copying Troy Powers and Andy Stone's Song from 1989 – which is also called All I Want for Christmas Is You – in a 2023 lawsuit, in which they claimed that her vacation track from 1994 was both musical and lyrical.
But now a judge has established that the couple did not have enough evidence to demonstrate from Carey, according to people being scammed his track.
The Associated Press reports that Carey's request for a brief judgment was granted by Judge Monica Almadani on Wednesday.
The two songs were also analyzed by a professor with a musicologist, who described the two songs as 'very different', where the only similarity was 'common lyrical idea and Christmas song clichés that was released by Stone before'.
The number of Carey turned out not to have been violated on Stone's copyright because of their many differences.
Mariah Carey successfully received a lawsuit that accused her of tearing away the lyrics and melody of her hit holiday rack All I Want for Christmas is you from a different song, without infringing copyrights
Almadani made the decision in a court in Los Angeles and judicial documents from the ruling state 'There is an absence of evidence to support the case of the Non -Moving Party' that the song of Carey got heavy inspiration from Powers and Stone's track.
Moreover, it was acknowledged that Stone did not come up with the expression with the expression 'everything I want for Christmas, are you'.
Sanctions were also ordered against the claimants and their lawyers by the judge, who called their lawsuit and follow -up questions Frivolous, according to the AP.
She also said that their lawyers did not make a reasonable effort to ensure that the actual claimed claims have proof of evidence. '
The claimants also have to pay part of the suspect's lawyers, the judge said.
Carey's Co-writer Walter Afanasieff was also a co-suspect in the case.
It comes after Carey attended the IHeartradio Music Awards on Monday, where she went viral for her wild reaction to a music tribute before she accepted the Icon Award.
The obsessed singer had the opportunity to look both Muni Long and Tori Kelly a few of her hit numbers of the years during the ceremony in LA
At one point, however, we hear as a long together-the camera cut briefly to give Carey on X in an now-viral clip while she slowly turned her head off the stage and turned a silk-grid to her right.
Sitting next to the singer it was rumor that friend Anderson. Paak who could be enthusiastic about the grooving on the tune.
The 1994 track is a favorite on the holiday season; Carey saw the song perform during the 2023 Billboard Music Awards
It comes after Carey De Iheartradio Music Awards attended, where she went viral for her wild reaction to a music tribute before she accepted the Icon Award
Another moment that was also caught on the camera, Mariah showed with a big grin on her face – who slowly faded as the version continued.
Fans quickly shared their own thoughts about X, with one medal, 'Mariah Carey does not feel these performances and does not hide that fact. Lol #iheartawards 2025 #MariahCarey. '
“I have so many questions …,” wrote another and one added, “this will be a new meme! I tell you. '
A user typed on social media, 'Mariah looked at PPL who lol her songs, and a fan noticed:' Mariah Carey reaction to Muni who sang her song for a long time, just sent me Omfg. '
The obsessed singer had the opportunity to look both Muni Long and Tori Kelly a few of her hit numbers of the years during the ceremony in LA
Muni got on stage for a long time in the midst of the tribute to singing we hear together
The viral moment took place shortly before Carey the Icon Award was presented during the ceremony in the Dolby Theater
'The way Mariah Carey can't help it, but show her disinterest on her face, but I get it, I am the same as my face tells everything. She breaks me. Personally, however, I thought Tori killed it! “Another written.
It was added: 'Now mfs crazy on Mariah .. man Mariah Carey a real singer Bruh. Of course she doesn't want you to perform her song. '
'Mariah Carey High of Drunk during this Awards show. LMFAOOOOOO, 'And another questioned:' Okay, who has the tea about what is going on with Mariah Carey Cuz ….? '
