Thursday, September 19, 2024
Home Politics Trump claims Harris’s rallies are smaller. We counted.

Trump claims Harris’s rallies are smaller. We counted.

by Jeffrey Beilley
0 comments

Kalina Borkiewicz, Malika Khurana, Karthik Patanjali and Bedel Saget

The sheer support that Vice President Kamala Harris has generated at her rallies has shocked former President Donald J. Trump, who has long emphasized and often exaggerated the size of his crowds. He has said, often repeating falsehoods, that his crowds are much larger than Ms. Harris’s, and the Harris campaign has returned with its own digs at the enthusiasm of Trump rallies.

We visited six rallies—every campaign event the candidates held over a three-week period in August—in six states, taking photos, capturing video, and capturing 360-degree images to analyze which crowd-size claims were compelling. The analysis found that, despite Trump’s claims, both candidates draw similarly large crowds.

On a Friday night, Mr. Trump drew 11,500 people to the Desert Diamond Arena in Glendale, Arizona. Here’s what it looked like:

Photos and compositions by Kalina Borkiewicz and Karthik Patanjali

On a Tuesday night during the weeklong Democratic National Convention in late August, Ms. Harris drew 12,800 people to a campaign event at the Fiserv Forum in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Here’s a scene from that gathering:

Photos and compositions by Malika Khurana and Bedel Saget

The four other campaign events The Times visited were similarly busy, with crowds generally filling the space set aside for the event. The rallies were held in venues with a maximum capacity of between 6,800 and 19,300 people, although in some cases sections of seating were cordoned off and extra seating or standing room only was added.

Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania, August 17

Justin Sullivan/Getty Images (Las Vegas), Christian Monterrosa/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images (Savannah), Michael Ciaglo/Getty Images (Bozeman), Doug Mills/The New York Times (Wilkes-Barre)

For each of the six events, The Times counted the number of people visible in images taken shortly after each candidate began speaking, accounting for people in dimly lit and darkened areas. This number does not represent people who may have left early, before the images were captured, or arrived late.

Estimates of crowd sizes at campaign events

Haris

Sat, Aug 10 Las Vegas 6,200
Tue, Aug 20 Milwaukee, Wisconsin. 12,800
Thu, Aug 29 Savannah, Georgia. 6,200

Trump

Fri, Aug 9 Bozeman, Mont. 4,300
Sat, Aug 17 Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania. 5,900
Fri, Aug 23 Glendale, Arizona. 11,500

Experts say that the size of the crowd at rallies has no direct correlation to winning or losing an election. For one, event organizers can strategically choose locations with small capacities, such as buildings on a college campus that can hold only a few hundred people. The day of the week and time of day can also affect the size of the crowd and when people decide to arrive or leave.

Yet crowd sizes have been a sensitive subject for Mr. Trump throughout his political career, his fixation increasing recently as enthusiasm for the new Democratic ticket has grown. Mr. Trump falsely claimed that photos of crowds at Ms. Harris’s events had been manipulated using AI

In response, the Harris campaign posted a video compilation of moments from Trump’s rallies, showing audiences yawning. It also wrote in a separate post on Truth Social that Trump’s audience left the Pennsylvania event early, leaving “even more empty seats.”

According to the Times, people left early at two of Trump’s three events, including when he gave his speech.

Photos taken at Trump’s rallies show where people have left their seats. Below is a series of photos from his Aug. 17 rally in Wilkes-Barre, Pa., taken 13 minutes and a little over an hour into his speech.

Examples of crowd thinning during Trump’s speech in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania.

Malika Khurana and Karthik Patanjali

And here’s how the seats emptied after Trump started his speech at the August 23 rally in Glendale, Arizona.

Examples of crowd thinning during Trump’s speech in Glendale, Arizona.

Kalina Borkiewicz and Karthik Patanjali

The longer duration of a Trump event compared with a Harris event may have contributed to a higher number of early exits. Trump rallies typically arrived earlier in the day, and opening speeches typically started earlier and lasted longer. Of the six rallies The Times visited, Mr. Trump spoke four times as long as Ms. Harris.

How long the protests lasted

Please note: The start time of each rally is determined by the time the doors open.

The New York Times

Despite the limited correlation between crowd size and election results, the open bickering between the two campaigns over this metric suggests it has at least some political significance.

Large, enthusiastic crowds can also help energize the candidate himself as he delivers his speech, said Todd Belt, director of the Political Management Program at George Washington University. It can also contribute to a “bandwagon effect,” showing those who aren’t there in person that the enthusiasm for a candidate is real.

“While I don’t think these types of events change people’s minds, they do make people feel like you’re not alone,” said Betsy Reiser, 62, a participant at a rally for Harris in Savannah, Ga. “It’s really important to feel like you belong.”

The Times took 360-degree photographs at two-minute intervals and panoramic photographs at 15-minute intervals at the rallies, from the moment the doors opened until the end of the events. To determine the estimated size of the crowd, The Times manually counted people in a single photographic panoramic photograph shortly before or during the candidate’s speech, when crowd density was expected to be highest. The count was then rounded to the nearest hundred.

Note: The green dots represent the number of people Times reporters manually counted in the arena.

Graphics by Kalina Borkiewicz, photo and composition by Malika Khurana and Bedel Saget

Areas hidden from our cameras were photographed separately and analyzed, then combined with the main count where necessary. Photos were merged into a single composite image showing a 360-degree view of the arena. Photo timestamps, cross-referenced with official campaign information and recorded broadcasts, were used to determine speaking times.

You may also like

Leave a Comment

Soledad is the Best Newspaper and Magazine WordPress Theme with tons of options and demos ready to import. This theme is perfect for blogs and excellent for online stores, news, magazine or review sites.

Buy Soledad now!

Edtior's Picks

Latest Articles

u00a92022u00a0Soledad.u00a0All Right Reserved. Designed and Developed byu00a0Penci Design.