Damning new evidence comes to light in case of Colorado dentist accused of poisoning his wife’s protein shakes

New evidence has emerged in the case of a Colorado dentist accused of poisoning his wife’s protein shakes.

James Craig, 46, is accused of poisoning his wife and the mother of his six kids Angela in March 2023 with potassium cyanide, while conducting an affair with an orthodontist in Texas. He has denied the charges.

Ahead of a hearing on Wednesday, his lawyers have asked that all charges against him be dropped over alleged ‘outrageous government conduct.’

The defense claims prosecutors lied to a witness – one of Craig’s alleged mistresses – and coerced her into making statements. They want that evidence excluded, arguing it’s unreliable, as reported by Denver 7.

Prosecutors shot back at the defense team, claiming their motion is motivated by desperation, as the witness’ claims are ‘some of the most damning evidence.’ In their response, they included some of the alleged voice memos between Craig and the witness, which appear to show them discussing Angela’s murder.

Colorado dentist James Craig was arrested for murder after detectives discovered his wife Angela Craig, 43, had been fatally poisoned

 Angela started feeling unwell after drinking a shake that her husband made for her on March 6, 2023

One message, from February 2, 2023, read: ‘Do you know anyone who can help me with my problem down here? I can pay handsomely. I want to be with you.’

Another from February 3, 2023, said: ‘Hitting up a homeless person actually sounds like the only choice right now. I made $66,000 in January and I want desperately to share that with you and help you. I feel so trapped.’

A third, on February 15, 2023, added: ‘I’m looking forward to Thursday night so much! Maybe we can come up with a solution. I love how resourceful you are. I want to bless your life.’

Craig is also charged with a felony count of solicitation to commit tampering with physical evidence after it was revealed that he had tried to persuade one of his daughters to dispose of key evidence in the case against him. 

The dentist was also previously accused of trying to convince a fellow jail inmate to plant suicide letters in his residence. 

He was also charged with felony count of solicitation to commit tampering with physical evidence after it was revealed that Craig tried to persuade one of his daughters to dispose of key evidence in the case against him

After being arrested a few days after Angela’s death, the accused pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder and tampering with physical evidence in October 2023

Aurora Police Detective Bobbi Olson, the lead detective on the case, said that she spoke with an inmate who was imprisoned in a cell near Craig. 

She told the judge and court that Craig reportedly told the inmate about his charges  and asked them to place letters in his garage and truck at his home.

Olson testified that the letters were allegedly written from inside the prison and meant to appear as his deceased wife had written them.

According to the detective, the letters were meant to show that Angela was not happy with her life, felt suicidal and was aware about her husband’s affair. 

She testified that the entire point of those letters being written and spread across the house was so that law enforcement or defense attorneys could find them letters.

Aurora Police Detective Bobbi Olson testified that Craig reportedly told the inmate about his charges and asked them to place letters in his garage and truck at his home

James and Angela Craig pose for a family picture with their six children aged eight to 20

Olson also told the court that the accused murderer had offered the inmate free dental work or money in exchange for scattering the letters across his house. 

However, the inmate did not take up the offer and instead contacted the authorities. 

But defense attorney Andrew Ho fired back and said that pointed out that the inmate only contacted authorities after Craig’s initial preliminary hearing brought in media attention. 

However, the judge ruled the prosecution established probable cause and met their burden of proof. 

Mark Pray, 55, Angela’s brother, previously spoke exclusively to DailyMail.com and said he wanted to thank the Aurora detectives and the DA’s office for their ‘unwavering dedication for seeking justice’ for his ‘beloved sister’s senseless murder.’

Olson also told the court that the accused murderer had offered the inmate free dental work or money in exchange for scattering the letters across his house

In the days following her death a deeply disturbing picture emerged of the life lived by the devoted wife of 23 years and mother who committed herself to her marriage despite doubts and despite her husband’s numerous infidelities, self-confessed porn addiction and a worrisome gambling habit that ran alongside him, ‘running his company into the ground’

‘The heinous actions of her killer have left a void in the lives of her children, our family, her countless friends, and the world, depriving us of Angie’s love and light,’ he said.

According to Pray, ‘This cowardly act, driven by self-absorption, is a stark reminder of the depths of human depravity.

‘The recent revelation of evidence tampering serves as damning proof not only of his guilt in orchestrating Angie’s torment and demise but also of his utter disregard for the well-being of those around him, including his own children.’

Pray continued, ‘He manipulates and exploits anyone and anything to evade accountability for his monstrous deeds. However, his reckoning is inevitable. Whether in this life or the next, justice will prevail, and he will face the consequences of his actions.’

According to police records, Angela started feeling unwell after drinking a shake that her husband made for her on March 6, 2023. 

Over the next 10 days, she visited hospital three times complaining of nausea and dizziness, but doctors couldn’t determine what was causing her illness. 

Angela Craig was taken to the hospital on March 15. She died on March 19, after four days on life support 

On March 15, her brother took her to the hospital again. She had a seizure soon afterwards, lost brain function and died.  

After being arrested a few days after Angela’s death, Craig pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder and tampering with physical evidence in October 2023. 

In the days following her death a deeply disturbing picture emerged of the life lived by the devoted wife of 23 years and mother who committed herself to her marriage despite her husband’s numerous infidelities, self-confessed porn addiction and a worrisome gambling habit that ran alongside him, ‘running his company into the ground.’

DailyMail.com exclusively revealed that Craig’s latest mistress was orthodontist Karin Cain, 50, from Marble Falls, Texas. She flew to be by his side as his wife lay dying in hospital but has since claimed she knew nothing of Craig’s supposed plan to start a new life with her.

Text messages exchanged between the couple show Craig apparently feigning concern for his wife – even as she lay hospitalized, frightened and dying – who was suffering through the symptoms of the poison he allegedly gave her 

Meanwhile the 52-page probable cause document filed in Arapahoe District Court detailed the allegedly calculated and ‘heinous’ plot that saw Craig allegedly research and purchase poisons online then deliver then to his unsuspecting wife through potassium cyanide laced protein shakes.

DailyMail.com revealed Craig was having an affair with orthodontist Karin Cain, 49, who is currently in the middle of a divorce from her husband Jason

Text messages exchanged between the couple show Craig apparently feigning concern for his wife – even as she lay hospitalized, frightened and dying – who was suffering through the symptoms of the poison he allegedly gave her.

While Angela deteriorated in the hospital, Craig flew his mistress from Texas, rushing from his wife’s hospital bedside to her while telling Angela how much he ‘wished he could stay longer.’

It is a reality that shocked all those who thought they knew Craig and who had bought in to the carefully curated image of a picture-perfect family that he presented.

Living in an upscale development with parks, a nature reserve and playgrounds, the Craigs were a family who seemed to have it all.

But the probable cause affidavit claims that, behind closed doors, Craig drugged Angela five or six years ago, in an incident he attempted to explain away by claiming he intended to commit suicide and didn’t want her to stop him.

Meanwhile, his wife was struggling to stay in a marriage riven by his repeated affairs, dire financial problems, and addiction.

Craig allegedly drugged Angela five or six years ago, in an incident he attempted to explain away by claiming he intended to commit suicide and didn’t want her to stop him

Craig had arsenic delivered to the family’s home in Aurora, Colorado, days before he allegedly poisoned her  

According to the charging documents, it was in his office – in a darkened exam room – that Craig allegedly researched and purchased poison online. And it was to this address that he had a package containing potassium cyanide delivered March 13.

An earlier delivery of arsenic was found to have been made to his home on March 4.

The later delivery raised concerns when a staff member who had not got the message to not open what Craig described as a ‘personal package,’ opened it and could think of no medical reason for the purchase.

She Googled the chemical, labeled a biohazard, and realized how closely the symptoms of cyanide poisoning mirrored those being suffered by Angela.

It was Craig’s business partner who reported the concerns to a nurse at University Hospital. The nurse in turn informed law enforcement setting in motion the investigation that led to Craig’s arrest and charging.

His trial is scheduled for August.